Inside the mind of the Book of Mormon’s first antagonist — A review of Mette Harrison’s The Book of Laman

In the Book of Mormon, Laman and Lemuel often come across more as comic book villains more than fully fleshed out characters. As Grant Hardy put it, “In the Book of Mormon, Laman and Lemuel are stock characters, even caricatures.” In her new novel, The Book of Laman (with its cover art a stroke of brilliance), Mette Harrison implicitly poses the question: What might have been going through Laman’s head through all this? What might have led him to act the way he acted? To be clear, this is a work of fiction. Harrison makes no pretense to be doing textual inference; rather, she takes the broad events of First and Second Nephi as given and searches for a credible Laman. Her endeavor reminds me of Geraldine Brooks’s brilliant effort to flesh out David from the Old Testament in The Secret Chord.

The Laman that Harrison draws for us is deeply human and relatable. He mostly wants to do right, but he repeatedly fails not in small ways but in disastrous ways (he beat up or tried to kill his brother). She constructs a back story that explains Laman and Lemuel’s ongoing reluctance to trust their father even in the face of Sam and Nephi unwavering confidence. And she plays out what might have happened to Laman and his people after Nephi and his followers left. That time that Laman and Lemuel start beating Nephi in the process of seeking the brass plates? It comes after Nephi condescends to his brothers: “You want God to do everything for you. You want the Plates handed to you easily, without any risk.” Lemuel and then Laman snap and decide to “teach Nephi a lesson.” After a while, Laman narrates, “I should have said that he’d had plenty and backed away from him. I should have shown some self-control. But I raised the staff again and brought it down on Nephi’s head. It felt good to me. I admit it. I was that angry with him.” Where does this anger come from? Later, after an angel intervenes: “I knew that God had chosen my younger brother over me. I knew why. I didn’t have to look far to feel my own weaknesses. I wasn’t worthy to be the eldest son, the one Father entrusted the care of all his family to. No wonder Nephi had been put in charge of this mission.” Laman’s enduring feelings of inadequacy lend him to dramatic shifts of mood, including anger at his steadier, sometimes annoying younger brother. Despite this anger, Laman repeatedly wants and seeks to be better. He tries to understand his family and to serve them, until he falls short once again.

Despite this success, the novel often frustrated me. The novel glosses over what I think is one of the 1 Nephi’s most interesting exchanges — the convincing of Laban’s servant Zoram to accompany Nephi and his brothers into the wilderness. Once the brothers tackle Zoram and invite him into the wilderness — in the Book of Mormon, I’ve always been troubled by what I read as an implicit threat of further violence should Zoram fail to accept the invitation — Zoram “seemed almost mesmerized by Nephi…. He knelt before Nephi as if before an idol. ‘Please forgive me,’ he said.” And then, Zoram disappears completely from the narrative. No wife from among Ishmael’s daughters, no blessing from Lehi at the end of his days. Where does Zoram go? I realize this might sound like a reader who is annoyed when the film adaptation of her favorite book excises a beloved scene. I found the pacing uneven, sometimes drawing me in deeply and sometimes leaving me fatigued of the constant narrative in Laman’s head. The gender dynamics are surprising, with women occasionally serving as tempters: The first time Laman tries to kill Nephi, it’s at the prompting of his wife, a strong but bitter woman. At one point, before Lehi’s sons and the daughters of Ishmael marry, they all engage in a little ancient spin-the-bottle (“We threw lots and they determined who was to kiss whom”), which Nephi spurns (“This game was not of God”) until his love interest convinces him to engage.

And yet, despite a few frustrations, I find myself reflecting on Harrison’s Laman, even now, weeks after the finishing the book. I can’t get him out of my head. And for that, I thank Ms. Harrison. In her wonderful afterword, Harrison admits, “I’m still clinging on to faith by the skin of my teeth most of the time.” But, just as with her Laman, “there are bursts of brilliance that strike me now and again and convince me that there’s value in the struggle.” Truly.

Bonus points:
  • Laman at one point proposes a prototype Magic 8 Ball: “It would be great it they decided they didn’t like what [the Liahona] said, shook it up, and tried to read it again. Maybe it would say something different the second time.”

Here is what a few others are saying about The Book of Laman:

6 comments for “Inside the mind of the Book of Mormon’s first antagonist — A review of Mette Harrison’s The Book of Laman

  1. James Olsen
    October 21, 2017 at 10:06 pm

    I remember first reading a comic on my mission called The Book of Laman (or maybe Lemuel?). Comically snotty, arrogant oaf that acted like the stereotypical punk older brother. But creative. In my last careful reading of Nephi (detailed in my Reading Nephi series), I found Laman (or at least the Laman of my mind) a very compelling figure.

    And I don’t think there’s any way to give an analysis of Zoram’s joining the brothers that doesn’t manifest coercion. Even if they all felt as nice and friendly as could be in their heart of hearts—they couldn’t allow Zoram to give them away, and Zoram was in a radically disempowered position.

  2. David Evans
    October 22, 2017 at 2:22 pm

    James, I’m totally with you on the Zoram interpretation, and I wonder why we don’t give it more attention. I feel like we discuss Nephi killing Laban extensively but not Zoram’s “invitation” at all.

  3. Marc
    October 22, 2017 at 11:45 pm

    Great review. I haven’t read it yet, but have plans to in the coming months.

  4. Nunya Bidniss
    October 24, 2017 at 12:58 pm

    In his “Homecoming” series, Orson Scott Card did a decent job of framing an interpretation of why Laman might be portrayed as he is. You have to flex your creativity muscle to take his SciFi version of the story *back* to the ancient setting.

    However, once I learned about the Deuterononimic reformers and learned more about patrilineal tribalism, Laman is certainly explainable as written in the BoM.

  5. David Evans
    October 24, 2017 at 2:03 pm

    Thanks, Nunya. I thought I’d sworn off Brother Card (after Pastwatch, which I couldn’t stand), but who knows, maybe I’ll try him again.
    Nah, maybe I’ll just read a book about patrilineal tribalism and the Deuterononimic reformers!

  6. Jerry Schmidt
    October 25, 2017 at 6:34 pm

    Nice review. Based on the excerpts provided, the wannabe storyteller in my head disagrees with the preacher in my head. But despite that, I’m intrigued, and I’ll admit I already identify with Laman, sigh. And I’m the oldest in my birth family, too.

Charitable Comments Welcome